Emmy Nomination Reactions
If you’ve read my blog you know that I thoroughly enjoy television of the trashiest variety. While I may hold this mindless entertainment in high esteem, I actually sometimes prefer scripted television dramas over the ridiculousness of reality television. That being said, I realize I’m a few weeks late with this but I definitely wanted to comment on the not so recent Emmy nominations…because I’m such a knowledgeable TV critic and everything.
Let’s start with Comedy.
COMEDY
BEST COMEDY SERIES
Curb Your Enthuasiasm
Glee
The Office
Modern Family
30 Rock
Nurse Jackie
I like to think that I have a nice grasp on pop culture and what the masses would enjoy and gravitate towards to. Whether it is with music, a television show, or a movie, I think my pop culture barometer is fairly accurate. So, I sort of agree with these nominations. I’ll be honest though; I didn’t know Curb Your Enthusiasm was back and eligible for an Emmy. Also, I didn’t know Nurse Jackie was a comedy. Since I didn’t know either of these should be in this category that automatically rules them out as awful.
The Office and 30 Rock have been staples in this group since they’ve been created. Actually, not only have they been staples, but also as far as I know they’ve basically dominated this category. I’ll say this: 30 Rock is funny. The Office, not so much. Their time has passed.
With their passing, this leaves only two shows left. Modern Family and Glee. Both provide a breath of fresh air on network TV. Glee has brought show choir to the masses, and Modern Family has taken the progressive idea of the American family and brought it into our living rooms. Modern Family is a perfect blend of outrageous family dynamics combined with ridiculous stories, and in my mind they’ve created a masterpiece. Glee deserves all the respect and attention it’s gotten, but ultimately, towards the end of the season it fell a bit flat and lost its comedic “umph.” If I were a voting member of the Academy I would hands down give this award to Modern Family. Never have I seen a show that legitimately makes me LOL week in and week out. Not to mention, almost the entire adult cast received a nomination for their individual contributions to the show. That, my friends, is outstanding.
Honorable Mention: In my mind, I would take Nurse Jackie off and put How I Met Your Mother or Big Bang Theory in its place. Hate me for it, but these shows, and their ensemble, are fantastic.

—————
BEST ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES
Jim Parsons, The Big Bang Theory
Larry David, Curb Your Enthusiasm
Matthew Morrison, Glee
Tony Shaloub, Monk
Steve Carell, The Office
Alec Baldwin, 30 Rock
This category has been an ongoing battle between Steve Carell and Alec Baldwin for years. I’m happy Matthew Morrison was able to sneak in this category and shake things up, but ultimately I think he’s out of his league. If you take a long, hard look at Glee and the actors, their comedic strength just isn’t there individually (aside from Jane Lynch, who we’ll get to soon). I personally think Jim Parsons does an astounding job on The Big Bang Theory, but is it enough to beat heavyweights like Alec Baldwin and Steve Carell, who both have established television and film careers? I don’t think so. Either Steve or Alec will win this. Steve has confirmed he’s leaving The Office when his contract expires, and Alec has hinted at leaving 30 Rock when his is done. Both are in roughly the same spot, so this is a toss up. Advantage Alec Baldwin.

—————
BEST ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES
Lea Michele, Glee
Julia Louis-Dreyfus, The New Adventures of Old Christine
Edie Falco, Nurse Jackie
Amy Poehler, Parks and Recreation
Tina Fey, 30 Rock
Toni Collette, United States of Tara
I’m going to be completely honest here: Of these shows, the only one I watch is 30 Rock and Glee. I believe (and am too lazy to confirm) that The New Adventures of Old Christine was canceled, which means the show sucks and Julia Louis-Dreyfus (was she the chick on Seinfeld?) should definitely not win. Lea Michele is one hell of a singer, but her comedic prowess is slightly lacking. She’s funny on Glee, but I definitely think it’s because of her fantastic writing staff and not her comedic chops. I don’t know who should win this category, nor do I care who wins. Next.
—————
SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES
Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Modern Family
Chris Colfer, Glee
Jon Cryer, Two and a Half Men
Ty Burrell, Modern Family
Eric Stonestreet, Modern Family
Neil Patrick Harris, How I Met Your Mother
Dear Academy: Why must you do this to me?!
Jon Cryer, gtfo. Two and a Half Men is old and stale. Plus, you won last year. Yawn.
Everyone else is fantastic. The fact that three members of the cast of Modern Family were nominated in this category (partly because none of them are necessarily LEAD actors in the show) just reinforces the fact that Modern Family should win for Best Comedy. That aside, it’s extremely hard for me to pick between all these talented actors. Going strictly on portraying the role and how comedic I find it, I would narrow the list down to Neil Patrick Harris and Eric Stonestreet. Of the two, I find myself quoting and rofling at Eric more so than Neil. However, I think that’s because Modern Family is fresh and HIMYM has been around for a while and Barney Stinson has become somewhat of a caricature of what he once was. However, Neil Patrick Harris deserves an Emmy. He truly does. To be an openly gay man playing a believable womanizing manwhore is a feat few actors could accomplish and he NEEDS to be rewarded. NPH, I’d vote for you. If Eric Stonestreet wins I’d be just as happy though. He is, as Cam would say, faaaabulous on Modern Family.

—————
SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES
Jane Lynch, Glee
Jane Krakowski, 30 Rock
Kristen Wiig, Saturday Night Live
Sofia Vergara, Modern Family
Julie Bowen, Modern Family
Holland Taylor, Two and a Half Men
Again, Modern Family has multiple people in the category (do I sense a trend here? It has to win). But, I really don’t need to comment much on this category. Jane Lynch will take home the Emmy. No questions. If she doesn’t win, then I will personally fly to Hollywood and light a bag of skunk shit on the door of the Academy president. Glee is a great show, but Jane Lynch makes Glee comedic. Without her, it’d be half as funny and would resemble a more entertaining version of High School Musical as opposed to the brilliant show it is.

—————
GUEST ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES
Mike O’Malley, Glee
Fred Willard, Modern Family
Eli Wallach, Nurse Jackie
Jon Hamm, 30 Rock
Neil Patrick Harris, Glee
Will Arnett, 30 Rock
Yawn. Who are these people? Jon Hammlegitimately wasn’t funny on 30 Rock and didn’t Mike O’Malley host like… Global Guts on Nickelodeon? If I’m thinking right he’s Kurt’s dad on Glee, and I assume the episode about Kurt’s sexuality and whatever garnered him this nomination. Whatever. Neil Partrick Harris should win, again. If he doesn’t win Best Supporting Actor then he must win this. Give that mo an Emmy already!

—————
GUEST ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES
Kristin Chenoweth, Glee
Tina Fey, Saturday Night Live
Jane Lynch, Two And A Half Men
Kathryn Joosten, Desperate Housewives
Christine Baranski, The Big Bang Theory
Betty White, Saturday Night Live
Elaine Stritch, 30 Rock
Note to the Academy: Desperate Housewives isn’t a Comedy. It has NEVER been funny. That said, Betty White deserves this Emmy hands down. Her ish on SNL had me dying. If she doesn’t get it then Kristin Chenoweth should. Next.

———————————————
DRAMA
BEST DRAMA SERIES
True Blood
Dexter
Mad Men
The Good Wife
Breaking Bad
Lost
How dare you Academy. This is like picking between my favorite flavors of edible lotion.
It’s my understanding that Emmy nominations are made off of submissions by the networks of a single episode. I don’t watch Breaking Bad or The Good Wife. I definitely should, but my TiVo is filled with dramas that I feel obligated to watch, and it’s also filled with my favorite trashy reality shows. However, if I understand correctly, and nominations are based off a single episode and NOT an entire season, then I’m almost positive that the Dexter and LOST finales were submitted. Mad Men is a fantastic show and has had amazing success at the Emmys, but I personally find it a bit hard to stay attached to.
Based on what I assume are the episodes submitted for the Academy’s review (the finales), Dexter should win HANDS DOWN. Never have I been so disturbed, thrilled, anxious, and perturbed at the same time. The season finale of Dexter was without question some of the best television I have EVER watched. That said, Dexter will continue on for a few more seasons at least. LOST, on the other hand, is done. And at its prime LOST was some of the most innovative and captivative television ever. Because of that, and the Academy’s respect for LOST, I think it will win for Best Drama. If LOST doesn’t win, then so help me, Dexter better win because Season 4 was incredible.
Oh, and True Blood is awesome too. But, it’s not compelling enough to win over these shows.

—————
BEST ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES
Jon Hamm, Mad Men
Kyle Chandler, Friday Night Lights
Hugh Laurie, House
Michael C. Hall, Dexter
Bryan Cranston, Breaking Bad
Matthew Fox, Lost
Again, how am I supposed to pick this? I will say that major, major, major props go to Kyle Chandler. Friday Night Lights is one of the most underrated shows on TV and EVERYONE should watch it. It’s so unfortunate that it’s been screwed over the way it has. NBC has royally fucked over the show. I get why its tough to promote a show named Friday Night Lights, but seriously, when you have such an amazing show with an unbelievably talented cast, you should promote the shit out of it.
Back to the category. I honestly can’t pick. I would love to see Kyle Chandler win as a big F YOU to NBC and all the haters. But, I don’t think it will happen. Should he not win, I want to see Matthew Fox or Michael C. Hall win for their work. Honestly, I’d like to see Matthew Fox be rewarded for his efforts with LOST. As annoying as his character may be, I do feel that he deserves some recognition for being Dr. Jack Shephard.

—————
BEST ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES
Glenn Close, Damages
January Jones, Mad Men
Kyra Sedgwick, The Closer
Mariska Hargitay, Law & Order: SVU
Julianna Margulies, The Good Wife
Connie Britton, Friday Night Lights
I swear I’m not sexist.
I don’t particularly care for any of these women, besides Connie Britton. My god is she amazing as Tami, Coach Taylor’s wife on Friday Night Lights. Again, I would love to see her win as a giant F YOU to NBC and I’d die if she took a dump on all the other high-minded hoes in her category. But, that obviously won’t happen. Whoever wins this category, congrats to them. I don’t really care.
PS. Why the hell isn’t Sally Field nominated? I realize Brothers and Sisters is getting a bit blah, but she still out-acts all these other chunks in this category.

—————
SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES
John Slattery, Mad Men
Aaron Paul, Breaking Bad
Martin Short, Damages
Terry O’Quinn, Lost
Andre Braugher, Men of a Certain Age
Michael Emerson, Lost
Rep the Cedar Rapids Michael Emerson. As much as I may love CR and the fact that Michael Emerson has ties here, there is literally no question in my mind who should win this. Terry O’Quinn was BRILLIANT this year on LOST. I’m not saying this because it was the final season or whatever. I’m saying this because the depth of his character, and the way he transitioned between the “real world” and the “flash sideways world” was seamless. His acting talent shined like a beacon of awesome during this season and he needs to be rewarded again and again and again and again for it.

—————
SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES
Rose Byrne, Damages
Christina Hendricks, Mad Men
Archie Panjabi, The Good Wife
Sharon Gless, Burn Notice
Elisabeth Moss, Mad Men
Christine Baranski, The Good Wife
I didn’t watch any of these recent seasons. But, I have watched the first few seasons of Mad Men. Christina Hendricks, you have my vote. ;-D How you doooin?

—————
GUEST ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES
Robert Morse, Mad Men
Alan Cumming, The Good Wife
John Lithgow, Dexter
Ted Danson, Damages
Gregory Itzin, 24
Dylan Baker, The Good Wife
Beau Bridges, The Closer
John Lithgow. Next. The Trinity Killer? So creep and sadistic. I’m getting chills just thinking about it. What a terrific display of acting by John Lithgow. Absolutely brilliant.
Oh, and writing this is seriously reinforcing the fact that I should watch The Good Wife.

—————
GUEST ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES
Mary Kay Place, Big Love
Lily Tomlin, Damages
Sissy Spacek, Big Love
Elizabeth Mitchell, Lost
Ann-Margret, Law & Order: SVU
Shirley Jones, The Cleaner
Umm. I don’t watch these shows, so I can’t accurately comment. Sorry. But, what a weak category if Elizabeth Mitchell was nominated for her contributions in the series finale of LOST.
—————
REALITY (YES! MY FAVORITE!)
REALITY COMPETITION PROGRAM
American Idol
Dancing with the Stars
The Amazing Race
Project Runway
Top Chef
You all know Reality TV is my life source. But, it’s laughable how disrespectful the Academy is towards this category when the majority of programming on TV is reality television. Reality Blurred had a great write up on the blatant lack of consideration the Academy gives Reality TV. My God. Seriously. If they knew anything about anything about reality TV they would KNOW that Project Runway is god-awful and that The Amazing Race shouldn’t win EVERY year. Why aren’t shows like Survivor, or better yet, So You Think You Can Dance nominated? These shows are far superior to Project Runway.
Let me guess. The Amazing Race will win for the 8th year in a row for their stale ass terrible season.
If I had my way So You Think You Could Dance would win this category. The contributions this show has made for the dance world is astounding, and far superior to Dancing with the Stars. I consider it an injustice that SYTYCD wasn’t nominated and that nonsense DWTS was.

—————
HOST FOR A REALITY OR REALITY-COMPETITION PROGRAM
Tom Bergeron, Dancing With the Stars
Phil Keoghan, The Amazing Race
Jeff Probst, Survivor
Ryan Seacrest, American Idol
Heidi Klum, Project Runway
Heidi Klum? LOL. Really? She doesn’t even host. She looks pretty, attaches her name to the show, introduces the challenge, and then judges. That’s not hosting. Switch out Heidi Klum for Cat Deely and then you would have a legitimately competitive category. However, there’s no question that of all the Reality TV hosts Jeff Probst has the hardest job. He has to be isolated in remote locations, he plays a large role in the casting process, he has to be in the jungle, moderating and commentating competitions, leading tribal councils, and living away from friends and family for months. Jeff Probst should win this category hands down, over and over and over and over for as long as he continues to host Survivor. Sorry, Ryan, but putting product in your hair and shining your gayface twice a week live doesn’t cut it in this category.

—————
REALITY SERIES
Antiques Roadshow
MythBusters
Undercover Boss
Kathy Griffin: My Life on the D-List
Dirty Jobs
Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution
You already know how I feel about Kathy Griffin. If I were a voter, she would have my vote every time. But, she’s crude and has offended half of Hollywood. Because of that, I highly doubt she’ll get it. I’m betting this goes to a network show because they have lots of resources to get behind the show. I expect this award goes to Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution or Undercover Boss.

—————
All in all, I know I was a little late in getting this out there because of my vacation, but I hope you enjoyed my commentary and predictions. We’ll have to wait until August 29th to see what actually happens. Until then,
.pop off at me.